The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler

ORLANDO DEBATE: Open Thread UPDATE: ‘You Don’t Have a Heart’

Posted on | September 22, 2011 | 61 Comments

Nine Republican candidates will be debating in Orlando, Florida (Fox News , 9 p.m.) tonight and, rather than live-blogging, I’ll be aggregating and occasionally updating.

Karl Rove has “handicapped” the debate.

Thad McCotter is dropping out of the GOP race, after being repeatedly excluded from the debates.

UPDATE 9:25 p.m. ET: After the first commercial break, I think Herman Cain’s winning decisively so far. (Because I said so, that’s why.)

UPDATE 9:35 p.m. ET: Herman Cain just proposed eliminating the Environmental Protection Agency. Also, he correctly pronounced Chile: Chee-LAY.

He was praising Chile’s private retirement program, but I think he was also showing off the fact that he knows how to pronounce Chee-LAY.

UPDATE 11:15 p.m. ET: Frank Luntz couldn’t get his video clips to play during the focus group, but said that Perry’s “you have no heart” comment about illegal immigration was very badly received. Rick Santorum’s retort to Perry was very sharp. Overall, Mitt Romney was perceived as the winner, and Brett Baier had positive things to say about Herman Cain’s performance. (Chee-LAY!)  Also: Gary Johnson’s dogs.

UPDATE 11:40 p.m. ET: Allahpundit on Perry’s “you don’t have a heart” moment:

Perry’s answer is a transparent dodge, of course, and Santorum rightly calls him on it.  The question isn’t whether children of illegals should be educated, it’s whether they should be subsidized by taxpayers with in-state tuition rates.

Here’s the video:

Category: Debates, Florida, Fox News, Republicans

Comments

61 Responses to “ORLANDO DEBATE: Open Thread UPDATE: ‘You Don’t Have a Heart’”

  1. Anonymous
    September 23rd, 2011 @ 4:43 pm

    Apparently we owe an apology to those “German migrant workers” we hanged in the early 1940s.

  2. Anonymous
    September 23rd, 2011 @ 4:57 pm

    It’s probably too late for Mitt stop defending the mandate in Romneycare which is unconstitutional at any level of government, his assertion that the mandate is acceptable for states based on the 10Th amendment is ridiculous. He appears to be having some success in selling that idea. But other than the big government nature of the Massachusetts plan he can make a reasonable case for the rest of the plan. But other than the indefensible mandate he didn’t make any mistakes last night. Perry made several the heartless crack pissed off those he’s courting without giving him any advantage with anyone else. Wooing the open borders crowd away from Bachmann or Romney isn’t a winning strategy.

  3. Memo From the National Affairs Desk: Republican Nightmare Campaign Tour : The Other McCain
    September 23rd, 2011 @ 8:40 pm

    […] = 300; google_ad_height = 250; PREVIOUSLY:Sept. 23: RICK PERRY IN FREEFALL?Sept. 22: ORLANDO DEBATE: Open Thread UPDATE: ‘You Don’t Have a Heart’Sept. 18: Generosity, Gratitude and GonzoSept. 13: The Prisoner on Flight 1884Sept. 12: Fear and […]

  4. ORLANDO GOP STRAW POLL RESULTS UPDATE: Herman Cain Beats Rick Perry : The Other McCain
    September 24th, 2011 @ 6:39 pm

    […] National Affairs Desk: Republican Nightmare Campaign TourSept. 23: RICK PERRY IN FREEFALL?Sept. 22: ORLANDO DEBATE: Open Thread UPDATE: ‘You Don’t Have a Heart’Sept. 18: Generosity, Gratitude and GonzoSept. 13: The Prisoner on Flight 1884Sept. 12: Fear and […]

  5. LATEST FOX NEWS POLL: Mitt Romney 23% Rick Perry 19% Herman Cain 17% : The Other McCain
    September 28th, 2011 @ 6:28 pm

    […] the span of 15 days — Sept. 7 in Simi Valley (NBC), Sept. 12 in Tampa (CNN) and Sept. 22 in Orlando (Fox) –  have completely re-arranged the GOP field.EXPECT FURTHER UPDATES . . .Category: […]

  6. Herman Cain Rhymes With Hurricane: Fund-Raising Surges in Third Quarter : The Other McCain
    October 1st, 2011 @ 4:08 pm

    […] powerful surge in late September. Cain’s strong performance in debates Sept. 12 in Tampa and Sept. 22 in Orlando, followed by his shocking upset win in the Sept. 24 Florida GOP straw poll, ignited a […]

  7. Herman Cain Rhymes With Hurricane: Fund-Raising Surges in Third Quarter | Herman Cain PAC
    October 1st, 2011 @ 7:31 pm

    […] a powerful surge in late September. Cain’s strong performance in debates Sept. 12 in Tampa and Sept. 22 in Orlando, followed by his shocking upset win in the Sept. 24 Florida GOP straw poll, ignited a […]

  8. Herman Cain Wins NFRW Straw Poll In KC With 48.9% of the Votes – That Makes Three in a Row « Nice Deb
    October 2nd, 2011 @ 8:16 pm

    […] a powerful surge in late September. Cain’s strong performance in debates Sept. 12 in Tampa and Sept. 22 in Orlando, followed by his shocking upset win in the Sept. 24 Florida GOP straw poll, ignited a […]

  9. David Brooks: ‘You Know Who Has Some Sharp Pants Creases? Mitt Romney!’ : The Other McCain
    October 4th, 2011 @ 2:21 pm

    […] (on the Gardasil issue during the Sept. 12 Tampa debate) and Rick Santorum (on immigration in the Sept. 22 Orlando debate) who did the most in terms of “cold ruthlessness” against Perry.It is nevertheless true […]

  10. New Polls Confirm Presidential Surge of Best-Selling Author Herman Cain : The Other McCain
    October 4th, 2011 @ 6:26 pm

    […] Cain; Vultures Circle Perry’s ‘Sunshine Special’?Sept. 23: RICK PERRY IN FREEFALL?Sept. 22: ORLANDO DEBATE: Open Thread UPDATE: ‘You Don’t Have a Heart’/**/ […]

  11. CAMPAIGN FOCUS: Will Rick Santorum Be the Next GOP ‘Flavor of the Week’? : The Other McCain
    October 4th, 2011 @ 10:43 pm

    […] stumbles in three debates in September – Sept. 7 at the Reagan Library, Sept. 12 in Tampa and Sept. 22 in Orlando – were followed by Cain’s surprise victory in the Sept. 24 Florida GOP straw poll. Since then, […]