The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler

Brilliant: U.S. Gives Pakistan $1 Billion; Pakistan Helps Our Enemies Kill Us

Posted on | July 26, 2010 | 16 Comments

That’s the bottom line on the Wikileaks document dump, which shows that U.S. aid to Pakistan isn’t buying us any love:

Americans fighting the war in Afghanistan have long harbored strong suspicions that Pakistan’s military spy service has guided the Afghan insurgency with a hidden hand, even as Pakistan receives more than $1 billion a year from Washington for its help combating the militants, according to a trove of secret military field reports made public Sunday.
The documents . . . suggest that Pakistan, an ostensible ally of the United States, allows representatives of its spy service to meet directly with the Taliban in secret strategy sessions to organize networks of militant groups that fight against American soldiers in Afghanistan, and even hatch plots to assassinate Afghan leaders.

The White House has denounced the leaks as “irresponsible,” but what about the facts revealed? For $1 billion a year, we’re paying for Pakistan’s ISI intelligence agency to help kill our troops in Afghanistan.

Via Memeorandum. This story was the No. 1 topic today on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe,” which is monitored religiously by Da Tech Guy:

So on Morning Joe we have a panel of people all against the war commenting on it. (In fairness the entire regular panel is against the war anyway so they would have to have a guest on to defend it.) Is there outrage, is there anger and this kind of leak? Nah. . . .
[T]hey say it is info we mostly already know, no big surprises. Harold Ford makes the correct observation that war is generally not clean and easy and the administration needs to explain that to the public. Barnicle points out that “this is Bush info” is not going to fly.
Will anyone be prosecuted for this? Unlikely. That would depress the administration’s base that is already depressed going into a midterm. They may or may not care about Afghanistan but they sure care if it is lost on their watch.

More blog commentary from Weasel Zippers, Patterico, and SusanAnne Hiller at 73Wire, who points out that the Wikileaks documents put Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on the spot.

Category: Aghanistan, Military, Terrorism

Comments

16 Responses to “Brilliant: U.S. Gives Pakistan $1 Billion; Pakistan Helps Our Enemies Kill Us”

  1. Thrasymachus
    July 26th, 2010 @ 12:07 pm

    The first step is always facing facts, and the fact is we are at war with the Pashtun tribes, not the Taliban. The Taliban is just a name for those Pashtun rejecting the Afghan government, which is just about all of them. The Pashtun don’t want any outside rule, and want to live by their own form of medieval Islam, which by itself is not really a problem. The problem is they support Al Qaeda and believe Al Qaeda should have safe haven in their areas. This we can’t accept.

    Bribery is not an option. The Pashtun don’t get to decide whether they get to give Al Qaeda safe haven, and we aren’t obligated to convince them not to by building schools or irrigation projects or any other modern goodies. Once we get our heads around this- which is of course unlikely- then we can get on with the business.

  2. Thrasymachus
    July 26th, 2010 @ 8:07 am

    The first step is always facing facts, and the fact is we are at war with the Pashtun tribes, not the Taliban. The Taliban is just a name for those Pashtun rejecting the Afghan government, which is just about all of them. The Pashtun don’t want any outside rule, and want to live by their own form of medieval Islam, which by itself is not really a problem. The problem is they support Al Qaeda and believe Al Qaeda should have safe haven in their areas. This we can’t accept.

    Bribery is not an option. The Pashtun don’t get to decide whether they get to give Al Qaeda safe haven, and we aren’t obligated to convince them not to by building schools or irrigation projects or any other modern goodies. Once we get our heads around this- which is of course unlikely- then we can get on with the business.

  3. Gee in the middle of a War a group chooses to release… « DaTechguy's Blog
    July 26th, 2010 @ 8:09 am

    […] Update: Stacy links, thanks […]

  4. DYSPEPSIA GENERATION » Blog Archive » Brilliant: U.S. Gives Pakistan $1 Billion; Pakistan Helps Our Enemies Kill Us
    July 26th, 2010 @ 9:34 am

    […] The Other McCain is on the case. […]

  5. Joe
    July 26th, 2010 @ 4:09 pm

    And you needed wikileaks to help you realize this? It is also a wee bit more complicated than that. Pakistan is not one Borg mindset (although the current form of Islam being pushed there certainly is striving for that).

    The money we spend in Pakistan is supposedly to buy influence. We know some of it will be diverted. But better to use the money to shore up friendies in the Pakistan military and government.

    I am not sure that this is a good idea. I am not sure we are doing it competently. But I also understand not providing this money would have consequences too, perhaps worse than what we are dealing with now.

  6. Joe
    July 26th, 2010 @ 12:09 pm

    And you needed wikileaks to help you realize this? It is also a wee bit more complicated than that. Pakistan is not one Borg mindset (although the current form of Islam being pushed there certainly is striving for that).

    The money we spend in Pakistan is supposedly to buy influence. We know some of it will be diverted. But better to use the money to shore up friendies in the Pakistan military and government.

    I am not sure that this is a good idea. I am not sure we are doing it competently. But I also understand not providing this money would have consequences too, perhaps worse than what we are dealing with now.

  7. Old Rebel
    July 26th, 2010 @ 6:23 pm

    This is just the latest example of the self-defeating nature of this war — and of DC’s insane foreign policy in general.

  8. Old Rebel
    July 26th, 2010 @ 2:23 pm

    This is just the latest example of the self-defeating nature of this war — and of DC’s insane foreign policy in general.

  9. Estragon
    July 27th, 2010 @ 8:08 am

    How sensational and wildly inaccurate is it to say, on the basis of the leaked documents, that “For $1 billion a year, we’re paying for Pakistan’s ISI intelligence agency to help kill our troops in Afghanistan”?

    This is the sort of fact-free analysis I came to expect from the NYT under Pinch.

    It’s been known for decades about the extremist infiltration of the ISI. Previous governments hoped to co-opt the radicals, but wanted to keep them out of the Army, where the real power was for most of Pakistan’s history. The ISI was the answer because their main concern was India, and from a government policy point of view their extremism wasn’t a problem in that regard. And their islamist street cred actually helped forge cooperation with the Taliban and other Afghan Pushtun rebels fighting the Soviets.

    But it was never true they had “taken over” the ISI – the Army would never have permitted it, although there were rogue units operating outside their control for a long time, and some still able to. But the extra funding we’ve been giving the Pakistanis since 9/11 has been going to gradually identify and isolate or remove these elements and compared to the situation we began with a lot of progress has been made.

    Now, certainly if the Taliban has heat-seeking missiles they probably were procured through these rogue ISI contacts. But the leaks reveal a grand total of ONE chopper taken down – either the missiles aren’t up to date, the Taliban are terrible shots, they don’t have very many of them, or all of the above.

    The true villains here are the leakers and the publisher of the leaks. Contemporaneous communiques from an ongoing war could endanger our troops in ways we cannot imagine. This is a serious security breach which must be addressed immediately and with the full force of the law.

  10. Estragon
    July 27th, 2010 @ 4:08 am

    How sensational and wildly inaccurate is it to say, on the basis of the leaked documents, that “For $1 billion a year, we’re paying for Pakistan’s ISI intelligence agency to help kill our troops in Afghanistan”?

    This is the sort of fact-free analysis I came to expect from the NYT under Pinch.

    It’s been known for decades about the extremist infiltration of the ISI. Previous governments hoped to co-opt the radicals, but wanted to keep them out of the Army, where the real power was for most of Pakistan’s history. The ISI was the answer because their main concern was India, and from a government policy point of view their extremism wasn’t a problem in that regard. And their islamist street cred actually helped forge cooperation with the Taliban and other Afghan Pushtun rebels fighting the Soviets.

    But it was never true they had “taken over” the ISI – the Army would never have permitted it, although there were rogue units operating outside their control for a long time, and some still able to. But the extra funding we’ve been giving the Pakistanis since 9/11 has been going to gradually identify and isolate or remove these elements and compared to the situation we began with a lot of progress has been made.

    Now, certainly if the Taliban has heat-seeking missiles they probably were procured through these rogue ISI contacts. But the leaks reveal a grand total of ONE chopper taken down – either the missiles aren’t up to date, the Taliban are terrible shots, they don’t have very many of them, or all of the above.

    The true villains here are the leakers and the publisher of the leaks. Contemporaneous communiques from an ongoing war could endanger our troops in ways we cannot imagine. This is a serious security breach which must be addressed immediately and with the full force of the law.

  11. Watcher of Weasels » Watcher’s Council Nominations July 28, 2010
    July 28th, 2010 @ 8:51 am

    […] Other McCain – Brilliant: U.S. Gives Pakistan $1 Billion; Pakistan Helps Our Enemies Kill Us submitted by Virginia […]

  12. Bunni
    July 28th, 2010 @ 3:19 pm

    I think the WH is behind all this leaking.

    The NYT had meetings with them before the story was printed.
    This whole war is a waste of American lives, and we should get
    out of there ASAP. Nuke their poppy fields, and go home.

  13. Bunni
    July 28th, 2010 @ 11:19 am

    I think the WH is behind all this leaking.

    The NYT had meetings with them before the story was printed.
    This whole war is a waste of American lives, and we should get
    out of there ASAP. Nuke their poppy fields, and go home.

  14. This Week's Watcher Council Nominations are Up | Virginia Right!
    July 29th, 2010 @ 6:02 am

    […] Other McCain – Brilliant: U.S. Gives Pakistan $1 Billion; Pakistan Helps Our Enemies Kill Us submitted by Virginia […]

  15. Watcher of Weasels » The Council has spoken 073010
    July 30th, 2010 @ 8:50 am

    […] place *t* with 1/3 vote -The Other McCain – Brilliant: U.S. Gives Pakistan $1 Billion; Pakistan Helps Our Enemies Kill Us submitted by Virginia […]

  16. Watchers Council Weekly Contest Winners 7-30-2010 | Virginia Right!
    July 30th, 2010 @ 4:22 pm

    […] place *t* with 1/3 vote -The Other McCain – Brilliant: U.S. Gives Pakistan $1 Billion; Pakistan Helps Our Enemies Kill Us submitted by Virginia […]